Case Study 13 : Protecting Professionals – A Real Estate Firm and the Role of Professional Liability Insurance

Background

Ridgefield Realty Services is a mid-sized real estate agency based in Kochi, Kerala. The firm has built a solid reputation over the past 10 years, handling property transactions, lease agreements, and real estate investment consultations. Recently, Ridgefield expanded its services to include legal documentation advice and property valuations, areas requiring specialized knowledge and precision.

The firm’s Managing Director, Anand Nair, noticed an increase in client disputes. In one instance, an agent miscalculated the market value of a commercial property, leading a client to overpay by ₹20 lakhs. In another, an error in a lease agreement’s termination clause resulted in litigation, costing the firm significant legal fees.

Though Anand ensured these cases were resolved amicably, he began to worry about the financial and reputational risks of such errors. He learned about Professional Liability Insurance (PLI), often called Errors and Omissions (E&O) Insurance, which protects professionals and firms from claims of negligence or inadequate performance.

The Dilemma

Anand faces a critical decision: should Ridgefield invest in PLI? His key concerns are:

1. Cost vs. Benefit: The premiums for E&O insurance would amount to ₹10 lakhs annually. While the firm can afford it, Anand is unsure if the investment is justified.
2. Coverage Limitations: The policy does not cover fraudulent acts, regulatory fines, or damages from intentional misconduct. He wonders whether such exclusions reduce the policy’s utility.
3. Employee Morale: Some employees believe the insurance might create a false sense of security, leading to complacency.

Anand decides to consult his management team to evaluate the risks, benefits, and potential implications of purchasing E&O insurance.

Discussion Questions

1. Risk Analysis: What are the key risks Ridgefield Realty faces that E&O insurance can address?
2. Cost-Benefit Analysis: Should Ridgefield invest in E&O insurance? What factors should be considered in making this decision?
3. Employee Management: How can Anand balance the protection offered by insurance with the need to maintain a high level of employee accountability?
4. Reputation Management: How does having E&O insurance influence the firm’s reputation with clients and stakeholders?
5. Strategic Alternatives: If Ridgefield decides against insurance, what risk management strategies could be implemented instead?

Assignment for Students

1. Prepare a 5-slide presentation recommending whether Ridgefield Realty should purchase E&O insurance, supported by data and rationale.
2. Develop a 1-page policy document for the firm’s employees on maintaining professional standards to minimize liability risks.
3. Conduct a role-play session simulating a client meeting where an employee must resolve a dispute involving professional liability.

This case study encourages students to think critically about risk management, financial planning, and ethical considerations in professional services.

If you want case studies related with your topics, please WhatsApp the topics to us, we will create and send to you….. (Our WhatsApp No: 9746264915)